I saw Superman Returns last night. 3.5 out of 5 stars.
I actually really liked it… the most striking thing for me was how Bryan Singer made Superman seem “real”. That sounds stupid; but, when he flew around there was none of that “Up, Up, and AWAAAaaayyy!” crap or fake “swoosh” noise as he lifted off. There was still, of course, the conceit that a simple pair of glasses somehow make someone look enitrely different and unrecognizable; but if you forgive that bit of storytelling, the rest of it was pretty good. I hope they make more.